Film Review
‘Cartel Land’
Cartel land is a feature-length expository documentary directed by Matthew Heineman, who embeds himself and his crew with both sides of the Mexican drug war, the ‘Autodefensas’, against the ‘Knights Templar Cartel.’ He also follows a team of vigilantes called Arizona Border Recon. The film mainly follows two protagonists, Dr. José Manuel Mireles the leader of the Autodefensas and Tim Foley also know as “Nailer” leader of Arizona Border Recon. This documentary is like a real-life version of Breaking Bad, but with more breaking bad…
The film opens with real-time footage of a cartel gang cooking meth in the outbacks of Michoacan. The Templar’s discuss their business of cooking meth as if it is an everyday thing to them, with no worry of the authorities, “F**k the system” (anonymous Templar).
The Autodefensas lead by Dr. José Manuel Mireles is a small army/ counsel, which united the townspeople to fight back and get rid of any cartel Templar otherwise know as Knights Templar Cartel at all cost. A quote from Dr. José Manuel Mireles “Article 39 in the constitution states that the power comes from the people if you are not united an idiot can govern you, so it is important that we come together”. And that’s exactly what the Autodefensas are doing. They are doing better work then the Mexican government.
The government notice this and sent the military stop the vigilante group and take away their illegal weaponry, without knowing that they were just trying to defend themselves from the cartels because the government was lacking in that. But the unity of the townspeople was so strong they started protesting to give the weapons back, which they succeeded in doing so. The military gave the weapons back and left immediately. The people cheered at their success.
Heineman mainly follows the Autodefensa as it is the most thought-provoking part of the story, which means that Heineman and his crew would have to go extremely close to the line of fire. One scene, in particular, a camera operator had to dodge behind a vehicle because the Autodefensas were getting shot at by the Knights Templar Cartel.
Knights Templar Cartel are drug lords that run any drug system in the state of Michoacan. They are people that think they are above the law and can do whatever they want, and they are constantly at war with the Autodefensas.
On the other side of the story, the crew followed the Arizona Border Recon soldiers – which was brought together by Tim Foley, because he was fed up with people doing illegal work “doing work under the table, not paying taxes”. Foley also is known as “Nailer” is a rugged middle age man who had a drug abused past, which he fought through after losing his job to those people going worker under the law. So he started the Arizona Border Recon to stop them from doing the same thing to other people.
Throughout the documentary, there were numerous of interviews and voice overs of the innocent victims that got caught between the drug wars. Each interview brought an aspect of emotion to the film, which worked effectively in engaging the audience emotionally.
After following both sides of the war it becomes harder to recognise the differences between the two opposing sides. After the Autodefensas took Los Reyes, one of the largest cities in Michoacán they started to develop an ‘ego’ of power. With this ego they started to raid innocent civilian’s homes, abusing and accusing them of being apart of the cartel. They would also trash their houses and take what they wanted. The consequence of this was a loss of unity from the town.
Overall Heineman’s carried out his directorial vision through the use of his unique filmmaking techniques extremely effectively. he was able to bring a lot of great content to screen- his interviewees were fantastic story drivers, he brought the audience so close to the fight it was felt almost as if it was a narrative, which worked extremely well since Heineman’s was actually able to capture it in real-life instead of using a made-up scene and set.
REFERENCE:
Cartel Land. (2018). Rottentomatoes.com. Retrieved 30 April 2018, from https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/cartel_land/
Macnab, G. (2018). Cartel Land, film review. The Independent. Retrieved 30 April 2018, from https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/reviews/cartel-land-film-review-10485413.html
Cartel Land. (2018). Time Out London. Retrieved 30 April 2018, from https://www.timeout.com/london/film/cartel-land
Felperin, L. (2018). Cartel Land review – audacious journey into the illegal drugs trade. the Guardian. Retrieved 30 April 2018, from https://www.theguardian.com/film/2015/sep/03/cartel-land-review-mexico-illegal-drugs-trade
Stan. (2018). Play.stan.com.au. Retrieved 30 April 2018, from https://play.stan.com.au/programs/1180649